Showing posts with label MBA overview. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MBA overview. Show all posts

Sunday, August 12, 2007

Completed the ealrier article - Differences in preparation

In case you have not noticed, I completed my second article in the preparation for MBA - "Differences in Preparation – Overview of preparation for US MBA - II"

Sunday, July 29, 2007

Differences in Preparation – Overview of preparation for US MBA - II

Here is the second post (Completed). Again, the disclaimer holds true - My opinions are not unquestionable. These reflect my understanding and not the view of admission officers.

Before I start, let me tell you two major points that get ignored -

1. MBA selection is as much about you selecting a school as much about the admission committee selecting you! If you dont like the school or its culture, DO NOT apply for it. If you do, you would not feel part of it and will regret that. You might take a year off and prepare better for a school that you are a good fit for. If a school is not a good fit for you, the ad com also can read this from the essays and will figure this out.

2. Be yourself. It is difficult to lie and keep it consistent across all the application materials - Beliee me, if you lie in an essay, the other essays, the recommendations or the interview will let your lie out. All the application materials need to be consistent with each other - whatever your essay says should be tied with what your recommender tells about you with what the interviewer perceives your persoanlity is.

The goal of this post is
1. to outline the documents/things needed for application for a top - B School ( read top 15 B schools) in US
2. what the admission people look for

At the end of this article, I hope you will also get the differences between the US admission system and the Indian System. Most importantly,

Let me start with Part 2 - what the admission people look for as I can emphasise the things to be highlighted in the context of what is a good application when we discuss the various documents required.

Part 2: ( what the admission committee looks for )

The admission committee tries to maximise the diversity of the class, ensure that you have high chances of succeeding in your career and finally are fit with the culture.

1. Diversity: All the top B - schools in US want to have a class that is as diverse as possible in terms of profession, education, background, attitude, gender, race etc... This is encouraged so that every person gets a multi-faced experience and hears the diverse opinions of fellowmates, which enriches the class-room discussions and the whole MBA experience. This can be seen during study groups too. Each study group contains maximum diversity - No two people in a study group ( generally a team of 6 ) would be from the same country or same gender or same backgroud. This brings in varied perspectives and diverse opinions - which is a tough challenge to work with, but a great learning experience. Hence, to summarise, if by being a part of the class room, you bring more diversity, you are in. Otherwise, no!. So, for example, if you are a painter or if you are a theatre artist, you have higher chances of admissions in a top B School in US. Yes you guessed it right - hailing from software field is a bane becuase most of the people who apply from India, would be from software. ( But dont worry guys, it is because of software industry and the high salaries of software that you can dream about doing MBA at US! - atleast thats what I told myself and its true though - Imagine belonging to a non-software industry - would you dream of spending fortune to do MBA in a top B school in US? I would definitely not! ).

Anyway, the good thing is that although we all come from software, we will definitely have different unique personality and experiences. Try to show that out - For example,in my personal case, I showed how I was diverse as I came from a small town background who had to work hard to get to where I am now. I also showed them that though I was in software field, I was differnet because of my experiences.


2. Success Rate: The admission committee wants people who are not only worthy enough of representing the school name, but also can enhance the credibilities of the school in the long term. Network in a US top B School is a major investment and a major leverage too! Each school wants its alumni to rise to top positions - this not only builds the alumni network apart from bringing in more contributions, but also is important for the credibility of the school!

Obviously, each school definitely has its own set of metrics that determine whether you would succeed in the long run - although its not a formal system, they would have an informal evaluation mechanism. Some of the common ones are 1. Analytical Skills 2. Team Skills 3. Leadership skills ( and style ) 4. Passion about what you want to in your career 5. Values.

3. Culture: Each school has its own style and culture - some might be a 'friendly' culture, while for others it might be a 'team culture' and for others it might be 'uptight'. The admission committe wants to ensure that you are a good fit for the culture - they want you to fit well so that you can have a great time at the school. For example, some schools like Tuck, Stanford, Berkeley are small in size, which means each person would be familiar and be close to the other students and more like family-oriented culture.The culture would generally be a friendly and warm culture (I am no where mentioning that the other schools are not friendly, it is just that some emphasise on one aspect and some dont). On the other hand, some schools like Duke focus on team work a lot ( The people are friendly too - no doubt, I cant doubt it, as my husband is a Dukie :)- ). The location also affects the culture -some schools are in a small town, which means the studetns have high chances of hanging out together and hence get closer more and some are in a city giving each student higher chances of hanging out far away from each other.

Part 1: (the elements of an MBA application)
The goal of the entire application is to see the above qualities - the diversity you bring in, the high rate of success you would have in your career and the fit with the culture - the things part of an application procedure are

1. Essays: Generally, each application contains 5-6 essays that need to be composed. These essays are typically to showcase your personality - your passion about what you want to do with your life - the clarity of long term and short term goals is used partly to determine that-, your team work, leadership style, your diversity and your values.

Typically, one question would ask you about what your long term and short term goals are and how an MBA from the school would help you attain that. In addition to being clear about your short term and long term goals, your story has to be practical, passionate and of course should demonstrate how you value the school ( Dont think the admission committe is doing that to read good things about their schools and be flattered ;) Apart from that( now, dont tell this to any adcom:) ), it is a way to understand whther you really wnat to be in that school or are you to "apply just in case" to the school ).

Another question would be to see your team skills and another would revolve around leadership style.

Go through the list of questions for each school and you will get a sense of what the school is looking at. A school that gives a lot of importance to leadership might focus on more leadership in its essays, whereas a school that focuses on team work might emphasise on team skills ( Eg. Duke School of Business)

The word limit depends on the school. Some schools have explicit word limit ( +/- 10% of the word limit is acceptable ). On the other hand, some schools dont - It becomes tough in those cases - look for sites like admitted.com and others to see what the consultants say as an acceptable limit.


2. Resume: The resume needs to be 1-page , unless you have a work-ex of 10 years and too many accomplishments. A CAR format is preferred - Each bullet point should start with Context, Actions that you took and the result that you achieved.

The best thing is to show your resume to a totally new person and get him/her to explain what he sees when he reads the resume. This way you would understand how an admission committe would be reading it.

Generally, your most recent experience goes first.

Some points to consider:

1. If you have made good progress in career, its a great place to show that - Again,by showing that you have consistently progressed, you show that you have high rate of succeeding in the future.
2. If you have any extracurricular/diverse skills/ know several languages - you can write it down in the Misc part of your resume - This will definitely get read. For example, if you have trekked a mountain, won awards in sports or even if you are a band member - dont forget to mention this.
3. Maintain a balance between work and education. For those, with fewer years of experience, dont focus too much space on education - there are chances that people consider that you did that becuase you dont have many accomplishments at work.
4. If you have done charity work, make sure you write about it.

Finally, dont underestimate the work on resume - It would dfienitely take several versions especially if it is the first time and might take atleast a week. Plan ahead.

In some yahoo groups ( sept-intake-2006 or in the archives ), you might find resume books of students from different schools. Use that to understand how a resume should look.


3. Recommendations: Generally, almost all the schools with the exception of Stanford and Harvard( these want 3 recommendations) mandate 2 recommendations ( another one is optional, however not generally advised to do so).

Again, the schools want the recommenders to provide ratings of some qualities and description of your personalities in some of the questions. The questionairre is a mix of ratings and description oriented. As you probably guessed, though the questions to recommenders are not the same as those in your essays, it would be a good mechanism to see the consistency across all the elements. The recommender's viewpoint about your leadership style must be the same as what you have written. Or for example, if there is an outstanding accomplishment in your resume, say related to work, and the recommender does not even mention it directly. It rings bells that there is something fishy going on.... There should be consistency of personality across essays, recommendations and resume.

The recommendations should ensure that 1. it helps the adcom to evaluate consistency ( mentioned above ) 2. it gives more additional information not already given as much as possible. So, each recommender must be chosen with respect to the above perspective. After you choose your first recommender ( generally immediate supervisor), the second recommender should be chosen so that he/she underlines a different side of you or different things that you have done which is at the same time consistent with your resuem nad essays.



Coming to the most important question of whom to choose - the most common mistake people make - they higher the recommender's position, the more the recommendation carries weight! I cannot imagine something more glaringly wrong than this. The criteria should be how well the recommender knows you and not what his/her title is. Title is important too ( dont discount it), but the first priority is what I said above. For this reason, the best person (and most valuable person) to take one recommendation from is your immediate supervisor. If you have shifted jobs or you have joined a company recently ( in which case, the immediate supervisor does not know about you a lot), then you might want to consider an ex-supervisor. Unless you have a solid reason not to choose your immediate supervisor, you should always take one from an immediate supervisor who knows you a lot. Now, you must be thinking, oh shit, I never knew I had to maintain good relations with my ex'es too :) I hope not.

Forgot to add, if you are an entrepreneur or into non-profit, if there is an investor or a top client - you could take from them. You could take from your partners/other primary equity holders in the firm.

The second recommendation could be from someone with whom you have dealt outside your primary work responsibilities. This might be related to some extra curriculars that you involved with in your work or if you had a part time job/were trying to start something, a person who is in a higher position of authority and can write for you.

The third one ( mandatory for a few schools ) again would be to show a different side.

Use the optional essay if you think that there was some side of you that did not come across in the recommendations and you want to show it. ( Do not use it generally, unless the "added-value" is significantly higher )

Some points to remember

1. Dont go for a generic recommendation and go for school-specific form: The schools give an option of writing a generic recommendation that talks about all the qualities instead of answering the specific questions the school asks. Unless the recommender is extremely busy, my personal opinion is do not go for it. It either decreases the quality of the recommendation because obviously there are chances that certain things get missed as each school looks for different things or the recommendation is too lengthy that the adcom has to do a lot of work in figuring out the answers to the questions they want to find out. In additon, that would show that the recommender cannot spare time for you.

That is also the reason why you should not apply to schools just for sake of applying.

2. Give advance notice to recommenders and set milestones from him about deliverables: This might seem simple, but believe me, almost every MBA applicant faced a problem related to this. Either the recommender would postpone until the last minute and finally, in the last minute, fill out some junk without thinking through or would ask you to write and he would endorse. Now, you do not want the former route but it is not bad, but the latter is definitely the worst possible option. So, set milestones accordingly to the recommender.

3. Ensure that you help and set tone for the recommenders when writing a recommendation: Writing recommendations is not an easy task. Especially for 5 or 6 schools. First of all, the recommenders need to think about what your accomplishments were. Secondly, writing is a pain especially amidst their crazy schedules. Thirdly, 5-6 schools is a lot unless they have been doing a lot of writing! Anyways, let me give you things that worked well with recommenders for me ( I can say that I was quite successful not only because I am in a top 3 B-School but also because one of my recommenders reviewed his grammar book for writing recommendations).

How to get the max from recommenders:

a. Most importantly, it is a relationship building process not necessarily for the sake of MBA. You need to invest in it continuously and over a long term period. I just cannot overstress the importance of this one. The recommenders need to put in a lot of effort to deliver a quality recommendation.

b. Finish your resume and at least the major long term/short term goals essay before you talk to the recommender. You would identify the theme for your essays. Then, if you show them your resume and goals essay, they would get an idea of what your essays theme is. Also, by showing the resume, you would help them recollect your accomplishments.

Also, set the tone for them - the major things tha tyo uare emphasising in your application, the achievements that you would like to talk about and the stereotypes that you would like to ask their help to overcome. For example, in my personal case, as I had 3 years of experience only by the time I applied to B-School, there is the general stereotype that it is too short a time and people are quite "immature". I needed to consciously eliminate this stereotype. So, I told my recommenderst hat this would be one area where the admission committee would be keen about and requested the recommenders to pro-actively include about this.

c. Even before you start your resume and essays, be open about your MBA plans ( unless it hurts your career progress ) and keep them updated about your MBA application process. When you finish giving your GMAT, update them and keep telling them what hte next steps are at every stage of the project.

d. Offer help about the recommendation process, but leave the whole process upto them in whatever way they wanted to do: Some recommenders take the rules very strictly and would like to do everything themselves, but do offer help and dont hesitate to do a couple of errands for them.

4. GMAT Score : As mentioned earlier, being Indian sets high expectations especially if one aims for a top school - at least above 700s. Now, if you are a s/w engineer, you better have even higher. The expectation from everyone ( not necessarily Indians ) is that worst come worst, you would have at least 90% in Analytical section. ( Refer to my ealier post on GMAT preparatin for a detailed one).

Some schools dont mind if you take them 2 or 3 times, some do and some take the best score in each section. It depends on the school. Ask them for inputs about this.

Now, I know how different the Indian schooling is - applicants who did hteir schooling in cities have edge in english scores, while those who did it in towns or villages might not. But then, the best thing is to try your best and after that, use your background as a differnetiating point and use the fact that you should have overcome several obstacles because of that as a point of advantage.

5. Interview : Some schools have a mandatory interview along with application (Duke Fuqua, Michigan). Some schools have it on invite basis (like Harvard, Stanford, Wharton etc... ) and some schools like Tuck leave it up to you ( for Tuck, if you visit the school, you can give an interview , while if you are not, then you need to get an invite). It depends on the resources the school has - the admission committee strength, the alumni size in the place etc....

The questions that would be asked would be generally around the ones that you answered in your essays and resume. Now, the interviewers in most of the cases ( I dont remember that any school shows your entire application to them), have not gone through your application. Again, by reading the kind of essays and the stress, you would get an idea of teh questions the interviewer woudl ask and the qualities on which he would be rating.


The book by Richard Montauk "How to get into a top MBA school" is a worthy investment! I can vouch for it.

Differences in preparation between Indian System and US System: Obviously, needless to explain more, the US B-school selection mechanism is more well-rounded, looks at your personality rather than scores, takes into account lots of differnet factors - your leadership style, your team skills, your career progress etc.... and is more comprehensive. I definitely prefer the US system than the Indian system. In short, the indian system selects people based on number-crunching and analytical skills, while the US system based on your personality

Tuesday, April 25, 2006

Scholarship for writing GMAT

Check out the blog of Eric at http://beatthegmat.blogspot.com. The blog is a great collection of relevant material for preparting for GMAT. Use it as a supplement along with the soft copies at the gmail account I have stored materials it. He is also offering scholarship for 2 candidates for writing GMAT. Btw, if you are do not know Eric, let me introduce you. He is supposed to be one of the whiz SC people for GMAT. You have to write an essay for which you still have one week. If you are serious about GMAT, here is a lucky oppurtunity to aim at.
The http://www.beatthegmat.com/ , maintained by Eric himself, which is a forum to discuss GMAT issues ( more like scoretop.com) though this one does not have the VIP login etc.. I am sure he would add this... And yeah, good marketing Eric.. Keep up the good job... You have a great entrepreneur in you :)

Thursday, March 09, 2006

Preparing for GMAT – IV

Please note: This article is however by no means exclusive and is intended for basic introduction to GMAT and no way unquestionable. These is my understanding and my view alone.

Introduction: GMAT is a computer-based adaptive comprising verbal, quantitative and writing assessment sections. The verbal and quant sections are objective and are rated together on a total of 800 and the Analytical and Writing Assessment Section on a scale of 0-6. The duration of the test is around 3 ½ hours (AWA 2 essays– ½ hr each, Quant 37 questions - 75 mins and finally Verbal – 41 questions - 75 mins in the same order with 10 mins break between sections). ( Need to check this up.. ).

With good quantitative abilities and good English skills (for an average Indian), securing average scores of the top schools (ranges from 690-700) is quite easy. For those with very strong English skills, securing 750+ should be a cakewalk. This has a caveat in too. High scores of Indians being so common, the admission committee expect Indians (specifically Indian engineers) to have at least 700+. 700-740 range is “just good”. So target 740+.

As I have said earlier, the test is an adaptive test. The better you do initially, the tougher the questions you get and the higher your score. Your answers to initial questions carry a lot of weightage and this adaptive ness eliminates the chance to revisit your questions. Once answers are confirmed, you cannot come back to the question. This adaptive ness is also the reason why your mood on the D-day matters a lot. If you are those kinds who need time to get into the grove, be careful. In addition to having a good mood and concentration on the D-day, it pays well to improve your ability to concentrate for a long time. This is particularly important, as verbal, being the final section with inadequate time needs a lot of concentration.

Sections in Detail:

  1. Analytical and Writing Assessment: You have to compose and type two essays (half hour each). One on an issue – you need to either support or argue against the argument and the other one is to analyze a given argument thoroughly. You need to find assumptions made, evidences that could support or weaken the argument, basically evaluate the conclusion based on the evidences and logic given in the argument.
    The score range is from 0-6 although the worst case is 2. So cheer up :). There are two evaluators - a human and a computer! Yes, right. One of the evaluators is a computer-based program. That implies that your organization of the essay and the connecting words (conjunctions, hmm never knew my grammar was so good to recollect at least one of the seven parts of speech!) are highly important. Content and points are important, but improper organization – you are doomed! So when you prepare make sure you have a well-organized template and a set of key words that you can use in the exam. Of course, use as many key words as possible.
    Having said all these, I should also mention that the AWA section is given the least importance by the adcom members. The computer-based evaluation probably explains the reason for this! They expect you to get above 4.5. If you get lesser than that, they might check your essays and if they are well written wonder who wrote them! Since the schools abroad are also bothered about English written skills, they might want to check your essays (Yes, they do get the essays you write in the test). By doing this, you are forcing them to spend more time on your application, which is a big risk.
  2. Verbal Section: This comprises three topics – Sentence Correction, Critical Reasoning and Reading Comprehension. SC: – 12 – 14 questions. CR – 12- 14 questions RC – 3-5 passages each with 3-4 questions totally 41 questions.
    SC: Here, you are given a sentence, part of which or the entire sentence is underlined. You need to choose one among four (or five, not sure) alternatives without changing the meaning. SC is thought to be toughest, but I would say its not if you can spend a lot of time. You make a resource investment on it and you have fixed and assured returns :) (Too much of stocks you see!) There are 7-8 grammar rules, which are basic enough, a thorough understanding of which will ensure that you get above average scores. If you need to move to higher ranges, you need to master a number of other rules, which can come up in the exam. In the last section, I will mention the books that are available, the difficulty ranges of each book and the time at which each book needs to be used etc…
    Master all these rules and you are safe even during your exam. Very less dependence on mood and presence of brain in the exam. Also, this is very important because the verbal section generally (there might be exceptions however) starts with 3-4 SCs. So, you could say that this being a computer adaptive test, a lot of the score depends on SCs.
    CR: Here you will be given a logical argument. You can be asked different kinds of questions – you might have to choose an assumption for an argument, evidences that will strengthen or weaken the argument, conclusion of the argument etc… With good quantitative skills, you would think it would be nuts not to crack them! You are mistaken. Some of them are quite tough and take a good deal of time to go through them, sort out the flow and finally solve the problem. CRs generally take 2.5 minutes and in an exam where you have 2- mins for each question, you have to pace up. Practicing and getting good accuracy in CR is the main trick.
    Practice many, get good speed and maintain good accuracy – you can get good score in this.
    RC: RCs unlike those in GRE and CAT are not simple. One, they take more time than we have on the exam. Two, they are tougher. They generally hover around – what would be a good topic of the passage, what is the inference etc…
    Many people, as I did, would believe RCs are easier and would tend to ignore them. But they are not! If there was anything that spoiled my exam (oops, forgot to mention my score – 710 – 95% in quant, 83% in verbal and 5 in AWA), it is my neglect of RCs. Another mistake generally done out of overconfidence is practicing without any time limits. Another one is practicing RCs of either too small or too long passages. Obtaining those of suitable length is very important from the beginning.
    If practice is important for any topic, it would be for this. And not just practice, but perfect practice :)
  3. Quantitative Section: Quant is pretty easy. You just have to brush up your basics and if you have given CAT recently, it’s a cakewalk. But just one caution: guard against silly mistakes. In the final exam, you will have enough time for each question. So you could cross check your answers.
    Ensure that you get at least 90% (that almost means not more than 2 mistakes at the end and no mistakes in the beginning), otherwise, adcom members would doubt your quantitative skills. Being an Indian, this would be disastrous!


    Books, Links, Test CDs and Other materials:
    There are several books that are available. The ones that I know are
    1. Official Guide (I think the latest edition is 11th edition) - This is the bible for GMAT. ETS or Pearson publishes this book. So, if you are lucky a couple of questions could pop up. Even otherwise, you can gauge the standards of questions, what kind of questions after going through this book.
    2. Princeton – The easiest of all the books – the best one to start with – to become aware of the kinds of questions and learn the basic stuff required.
    3. Kaplan – The toughest of all – read it after OG. – the final one.
    4. Apart from it there are several others, I have not used them. So cant comment on those. However, I have heard that Barons is one that’s not good. I ended up wasting money.

    Test CDs:
    1. You can take several sample tests. Ensure that you take at least 6-7 tests. It is very important.
    2. Princeton is supposedly the easiest and there are several contradictions about correlations of the score in Princeton with the actual score. So, I cant comment on that as well.
    3. Kaplan in the toughest one. You could add 50-60 points on the Kaplan score to arrive at your final score on powerprep test.
    4. Power prep – the most important – is a set of 2 tests released by ETS. You could download it on net. This provides a reasonable estimate of the actual score. But the caveat is that most of the questions are from the OG. So, if you take this at the end, you would probably remember the answers and would not solve them instead just go on marking them.
    5. Though not CDs, http://www.scoretop.com is a good site that contains several sets of questions that appeared in actual tests. You take up a VIP membership and you can access a few such sets. They are at the correct level of the exam.

    Other materials: RC, CR need a lot of practice and practicing questions of the same level is very important, specifically in RCs. For these (and SC as well) for more practice, you could use soft copies of collection of 1000 questions each. Practice these (1000 questions in each) you can be rest assured to crack GMAT. I have temporarily uploaded soft-copies of materials that I have in a Gmail account. I intend to start a group too, but looks like its going to be postponed further. So meanwhile, in case you need materials, mail back for the account name and password. Also, if you could create a group, move these materials, cheers :)

    Links:
    There are a few groups in yahoo that would be useful – future_mba, gmattutor,
    www.scoretop.com
    http://dave.blogspot.com
    General preparation strategy:

  1. Book your exam date - You could take a test and decide. Typically it takes 5 days for brushing quantitative section ( 10 hours each day ) and 1.5 months ( 10 hours each for English ) This is my average - do remember I do not have very good english skills. So modify this accordingly or better try to check this with others... Estimate how much time you require and book the date before preparation.
  2. Take an exam before starting out – One, you will understand where you stand. Two, you can determine your strengths and weaknesses. Three, it would give you a lot of familiarity with the type of questions. Four, you can evaluate what other things are important such as concentrating for a long time etc. You could take the power prep here. (Just remember, power prep is of no use taking after you have done OG especially if you are one of those with good memory)
    2. Start out with Princeton – complete basics of all the verbal section. Quant could be managed at the end. Practice questions.
    3. Take a test again
    4. Complete OG – for SC – OG is the best – Solve the question – assimilate the explanation – the explanation is succinct but very good. Believe me, you would take a lot of time understanding the explanation itself. CR and RC you can guage the standards from OG.
    5. Take a test again
    6. Go for Kaplan.
    7. Take a test, see your weaknesses. Use 1000 SCs, 1000CRs, and 1000 RCs for practice to overcome them.
    8. Take tests in the final week.
    9. Appear for the exam

    Score well :)
    Finally, give me a treat :D

MBA Preparation - Slight Change in the order of Posts

I will be posting an article about preparation for MBA. The preceding two articles - Differences in Preparation and Calendar will be posted later. Meanwhile, for these, you could check the articles written by Sowmya ( aka Simbha) earlier. You could also refer to Swetha's ( She is currently doing her MBA at Univ. of Wisconsin ) articles at http://swetha.balla.googlepages.com/mbagyan.
Some of my friends have booked their gmat dates and wanted me to complete the GMAT preparation info. They scolded me into writing this :( Thanks to them anyways, their scoldign did have impact! I have been wantign to complete these two articles before posting them, but looks like I am postponing them a lot. With things getting busier, I am not sure if I can post them soon ( soon = 2 weeks). So the next article would be about GMAT preparation.
Sorry for the inconvenience.

Thursday, February 16, 2006

International MBA versus Indian MBA – I

Before you start with the preparation, the first thing to understand is what are the things involved in an international MBA and whether it is suitable. Given the vast number of schools both in India and abroad let me be more specific about the range and ranking of schools that I am considering. For the Indian B Schools, it would be the ones in the IIM leagues while on the other hand for the international schools, it would be those ranked below top 25. Here are the arguments for why you should pursue an international MBA. Also, note that these are strictly my views and in no way proclaimed to be absolutely correct!

  1. Diversity: You would be on a study group with a painter from Turkey, a consultant from a top-shot consulting firm in US, an investment banker, a serial entrepreneur in Israel and a writer from Russia. Imagine the arguments, the discussions, and team issues cropping up. Something seemingly trivial would seem very important to your teammate. You would be exposed to working with people belong to different cultures, nationalities, languages, industries, hobbies, genders and finally different mindsets and attitudes. The experience would break you free from your shackles and limitations of thought process and enrich your experience beyond the classroom. This great learning curve that happens beyond the classroom is a stepping-stone to your experiences as a future successful manager.
  2. Alumni Connections: Needless to say, alumni of top international B school are very strongly connected. The schools view their alumni to be their biggest assets. Infact, one of the criteria during selection would be how well the student would contribute as alumni. One of the criteria for rankings (Nope, I don’t remember which of the several rankings) of international B-schools measures the maximum gift amount that has been given to the school by alumni. Because the students themselves are diverse, choose several fields, are spread across several nations and most importantly have a sense of community, you can tap into the network easily.
  3. Brand Recognition: It’s quite obvious that you can use the brand of a top school for a lifetime. A few top schools may not be so well recognized in India as they are in US, but believe me, schools are doing a great deal to promote their brand in India. In a few cases, alums are taking up initiative in doing this. Even if a person in India does not recognize the name of the school, you tell him the rank of the school and a few contacts you know, you would get your job done (all right! It’s an exaggeration, I agree, but I hope you get my point).
  4. Global Exposure: The global exposure that you gain would be immensely valuable. Please note that this is different from diversity. Diversity is more about what you learn because of your fellow mates, while global experience is related to your future career. The top schools would generally be in Europe or in US and these are the biggest investors in India. Several of them in today’s globalization want to shift or outsource things to India while some of them want to tap Indian market. For some of the IT companies, these nations themselves are the potential markets. On the other hand Indian companies want to acquire several companies in these developed nations and build a brand (you got it, for example Mittal). For these, you would be the best person. You have international experience with a solid Indian background. You would also be visiting different nations on field trips or in your internships. You would be able to understand the working culture, build important contacts and network and get insights into markets and trends, which would not be possible if you are in India. For those, who want to become Entrepreneurs, I guess you realized the importance.
  5. Strong Industry Connections: In several of the top schools, their alumni who are now CEOs of several leading companies would discuss their cases with you. Its not just limited to alumni, but even several other CEOs. I know you are going to tell me who said it does not happen in Indian Schools. Well that’s why I said “Strong”. Indian B Schools need to improve a lot on this front.
  6. Cultural Aspects: Please read my entire point before accusing me that I am undermining Indian Culture. I am proud to be an Indian and of course love India. What I mean to say is the culture out there does not “discourage” those taking risks. In India, you take a risk; you are viewed with skepticism and sometimes looked down too. (I am not taking sides, just giving my honest opinions). It’s changing, I agree, but long way to go. After MBA, you turn down a 12 lakh per annum offer and start your own firm - people wonder what is wrong with you. More so, with all the colleges publicizing their highest-paid salary each and every year, which is viewed as “the factor” for evaluating Indian B schools. I am not saying it does not make sense to earn well, because you want to lead a happy life. But taking risks on the way is discouraged by several social factors. In US, specifically, people take more risks. Although you would not be looked high and admired, you would definitely not be out-of-box.

    Having said all the positives, you must be wondering where is the caveat. Here it comes-
  1. Cost: The biggest and probably the only factor would be the cost of an international MBA. Scholarships are very limited unlike in MS/PhD. You do not have time to take up assistantships or part time jobs. At the same time, the cost of an international MBA would be around 40-50 lakh (in some of the leading schools might stretch over 50 lakh too). Son of a Birla, cool. No? Are you wondering how old you would be while accumulating the money? Don’t go into the hassles of calculations. Many schools, typically below 15, have tie-ups with banks for loans and act as a guarantee for your loans. You do not have to go through the process of finding your far relative and sending him gifts and cajoling him to co-sign your loan. You get admission into these schools; you need not search for loans. For the remaining schools, you need a US co-signer to act as a guarantor for your loan.

    The other caveat is that the schools prefer experienced people. The average experience at the top schools is around 4-6. Also, scoring high on GMAT alone would not ensure that you get a seat in a top school. You need to have a good application in its entirety. You need to have a coherent application - a clear view of your goals, good career growth, good extra curriculars, social activities etc… It’s basically a risk/reward strategy. The more you can contribute to the school by adding to the diversity, you are preferred. At the same time, you should not be a risk to the school as in they should not worry about whether your quantitative skills are good enough and whether they can place you post mba. The lower the risk and the higher the reward, you are in. So, if you are a painter or an artist, great, prove that you have good quantitative skills, you have a greater chance than an Indian IT engineer with 750 GMATs. They look at you as a person, your interests, your team skills, your leadership qualities, your contribution to the community etc… The effort to prepare a solid application takes a lot of time – in fact could go to a couple of years too. But remember, in the entire process, you understand yourself better and are getting better organized and concentrated towards your goal. That is the beauty of the process!

    One point that I believe is worth mentioning, if you want to do an MBA internationally, do so from a reputed one (typically below 25) unless you have scholarship or you have been given a waiver or an institute is famous for a particular concentration specifically. The reason is you would be making a huge investment, which if you intend to take a loan and finish the loan by taking a job after your MBA, you need to get a well-paid job (at least the salary should be greater than that given for a technical entry job typically $60K). For the colleges ranked above 25, the placements are not that good and would take a long time to repay the loan. The average post-mba is very low; forget about your dream companies and your options. In India, you would be wasting a small amount of money. Additionally, if you go for schools ranked very higher (numerically), I have heard you might get into visa problems. I am not sure, but do check that out. Also, if you intend to go into specific fields such as strategy consulting in a company like McKinsey or gain entry into VC field, you might not be able to do so in second–rung colleges.


    Do check this site too as it mentions some of the points mentioned here (and a few different). Sowmya, the authoress, has explained several things further.
    An International MBA - Part 2

Wednesday, February 15, 2006

MBA Abroad - Index Post

Many of my friends have been asking me very pertinent questions related to MBA from US. I thought it would be useful for everyone if I could write the most common set of questions. Thanks to Kopos and others, who detailed me the basic outline, here is my first article on various topics, which is a basic index. Feel free to mail me in case I miss out any particular topic.

  • International MBA versus Indian MBA – I
  • Differences in Preparation – Overview of preparation for US MBA . - II
  • Calendar for Preparing for US MBA - III
  • Preparing for GMAT - IV
  • Planning your career goals – IV
  • Starting the application procedure – Short listing schools – V
  • Pruning them in depth – Finer aspects of schools - VI
  • Resume preparation - VII
  • Writing the first set of essays - VIII
  • Recommendations - IX

    Dont be surprised to see the "Preparing for GMAT" and "Planning your career goals " have the same numbers. It is best if you can prepare for GMAT while at the same time take off time to you’re your career and short list the schools.

    Before you go on and read these articles, a word of caution. These have been written to the best of my knowledge and in no way unquestionable. Let me update my profile so that you read all the stuff and realize that I have just applied (and god forbid, dinged by all the universities) and chose not to rely on an amateur’s advice. I am currently waiting for my results, so you probably want to check my results before wading through :)

    Thanks to “D” for these set of posts,
    http://www.pagalguy.com/index.php?categoryid=8&p2_articleid=65, authored by Sowmya alias Simbha, answers most of the questions in the outline, easing my job to a large extent. In case of differences or on topics that I believe need more detail or has not been covered, I will post here. In the remaining instances, I will include suitable links.